A common theme of late (in my reading and conversations) is keeping emotion out of discipline. Perhaps this should be obvious within the definition of terms, but when it comes to parental discipline, keeping emotions out of the picture is difficult. This is real life, every day encounters. To succeed in being logical and rational 100% of the time is … well, it doesn’t happen! It can’t happen.
Some accuse me of being overly emotional, period. They may be right. And the lack of sleep certainly plays a part. (I haven’t slept consistently in eighteen months.) Or maybe it’s that the love I have for my kids already saturates our encounters with emotion. Whatever factors contribute, the result has me displaying too much when disciplining my kids. Not always, mind you. Sometimes discipline is easy. But on tough days, when I am tired or have too much on my mind, it’s not so easy. I quickly become weary of plating the same rules time and again. That exhaustion is evident to me and, unfortunately, to my kids. I nag. I yell. I beg and plead – all useless efforts toward gaining some obedience.
A friend shared with me this morning the struggles she has had with her daughter. Our two girls both want to dominate. They are both know-it-alls. They both will argue to the death over trivial topics. They are also four years apart. Julie (my friend) told me she is making a concerted effort to stop arguing. Consequences are explained and that’s it. The child then has a choice: either obey or disobey. The end.
That choice is always there, but I realized, after talking with Julie, that I often allow another option: the buttons. Instead of clearly stating the consequences and leaving it at that, I will allow negotiations. The whining starts, then the begging and procrastinating. I permit my kids to push my buttons. Why? I don’t want to punish them; I want them to do the right thing. But they’re kids! They don’t want to do the right thing. They want to test the boundaries and push my buttons. They want to see how far I’ll bend before snapping.
Old dogs can learn new tricks. This afternoon I showed one of mine. Lunch was over and so was Oswald. Every day the end of Oswald (one of Zach and Ellie’s favorite cartoons) signals naptime. I turned off the TV and made the announcement, as I do every day. The argument part of our routine then began. Isabel started whining and declaring how she didn’t want to go to sleep.
Normally I would work to persuade her, thinking a gentle response would validate her feelings and prevent further argument. It usually did validate her feelings – enough to engage her in further arguments. Instead of diffusing the situation, my response, marinated in emotion, simply added kindling to the fire.
Today was different. Without any exhaustion or frustration in my voice, I said, “You are whining. If you continue arguing and throwing a fit, you will get a spanking. Now, it’s time for your nap.” I was not rude or harsh. I was upbeat, simply stating facts.
She didn’t expect that. She started with her usual rebuttal, but stopped mid-sentence, drastically changed her tone and took a step toward me. Calmly she stated, “I don’t want a spanking.”
“Good! Let’s go take a nap.”
It worked! I didn’t need to get emotional. Keeping emotion out of it made my job so much easier. I wasn’t forced to negotiate or plead for obedience. I simply stated the facts. No buttons were left in the open. I was safe and she was safe to make her decision.
And it makes sense, doesn’t it? I am sure God is emotional, but we never see His emotion in His discipline. He is saddened by our lack of wisdom; our repeated poor choices, but He doesn’t negotiate with us. He doesn’t beg us for obedience or threaten possible punishments. He lays out our choices clearly and steps back allowing us to make our decisions. Oh, we still whine and complain, but He doesn’t honor that behavior. He just waits patiently for us to choose. If we choose the right, we are blessed. If we choose the wrong, we encounter the consequences. It’s a matter of fact.
Facts are great because they contain no blame. We can’t get mad at gravity when we fall down. Gravity is a fact. That’s just the way it is. If we fall, it’s our fault. We made a poor choice. The same is true with discipline, be it from us or our Heavenly Father. Our kids can’t get mad at us if they make a poor choice. If Isabel decides to continue whining and throwing fits, she gets a spanking – not because I am a bad mom, but because she chose that consequence over the blessing of obedience. Likewise, we cannot blame God if we make a wrong choice. The facts are safe; safe for God, safe for us, safe for our kids. The consequences are what they are, and the choice is ours.
Labels: discipline, parenting